What if the other driver lies about the accident?

Get a Free Case Review

SERIOUS ATTORNEYS FOR SERIOUS INJURIES

Practice Areas

FREE CONSULTATION
five-stars-BBGgold

Chandler Ross is the best hands down! You can not go wrong with these attorneys!

— Tracy P.

Getting into a car accident is stressful enough. But when the other driver looks you in the eye and tells the police a completely different story, that stress turns into real panic. You know what happened. You know who caused the crash. So what do you do when the other driver lies about the accident? If you were hurt near the University of Denton campus, on I-35E, or anywhere else in Denton County, the answer matters a great deal to your injury claim and your financial recovery.

Table of Contents

Why Drivers Lie After a Crash in Texas

Drivers lie after accidents for very practical reasons. They want to avoid a ticket, keep their insurance premiums from going up, protect a commercial driver’s license, or dodge criminal charges if they were drinking or distracted. In some cases, the lie is a panicked reaction. In others, it is a calculated attempt to shift blame onto you.

Texas is a fault-based insurance state, meaning the driver who caused the crash is responsible for covering your damages. That financial pressure gives at-fault drivers a strong incentive to twist the facts. A driver who ran a red light at Carroll Boulevard and University Drive, for example, might claim you were speeding through the intersection. A driver who rear-ended you on Loop 288 might say you cut them off. These false narratives are not rare. They happen regularly in Denton County.

Under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Chapter 33, Texas uses a proportionate responsibility system. If the other driver can push your share of fault above 50 percent, you recover nothing. Even a smaller increase in your assigned fault percentage reduces your compensation dollar for dollar. That is exactly why some drivers lie: they are trying to shift enough blame onto you to limit or eliminate your recovery. Understanding this motivation helps you take the right steps immediately after a crash.

Working with personal injury lawyers who understand how Texas fault rules work gives you the best chance of keeping your percentage of responsibility where it belongs.

Lying about a car accident in Texas is not just unethical. It can be a crime. Under Texas Penal Code Section 37.08, knowingly providing false information to a police officer during an official investigation is a Class B misdemeanor. That means the other driver’s lie to the responding officer at the scene, whether on Teasley Lane or I-35, is a criminal act if it was intentional.

The consequences go further when insurance is involved. Texas Penal Code Section 35.02 makes it a crime to provide a false or misleading statement to an insurer with intent to deceive. Under that statute, a statement is “material” if it affects the eligibility for coverage or the amount of a payment on a claim. A lie about how an accident happened clearly meets that standard. Depending on the dollar value of the fraudulent claim, insurance fraud in Texas can range from a Class C misdemeanor all the way up to a first-degree felony, with potential prison time of five to ninety-nine years for the most serious cases.

If the case goes to court and the other driver repeats the lie under oath, that becomes perjury, which carries its own criminal penalties. These are serious consequences, but they do not happen automatically. You need evidence to expose the lie, and you need someone in your corner who knows how to gather and present that evidence effectively. A skilled car accident lawyer can help document inconsistencies in the other driver’s story before they become the accepted version of events.

How to Protect Yourself When the Other Driver Lies

Your actions right after the crash determine how strong your case will be. The best protection against a false statement is hard evidence that contradicts it. Start collecting that evidence at the scene, if you are physically able to do so.

Take photos of every vehicle, the road surface, skid marks, traffic signals, and any nearby landmarks. If the crash happened near the Denton County Courthouse on Hickory Street or in a parking lot off Loop 288, there may be nearby surveillance cameras that captured the collision. Write down the names and phone numbers of any witnesses. Eyewitness accounts from people who have no stake in the outcome carry significant weight with insurance adjusters and juries.

Call the police. Under Texas Transportation Code Section 550.062, a law enforcement officer who investigates a crash resulting in injury or property damage of $1,000 or more must file a written collision report with TxDOT within ten days. That report is an official record. Under Texas Transportation Code Section 550.065, you have the right to request a copy of that report as a person directly involved in the accident. Review it carefully. If the other driver’s false statement made it into the report, that is something your attorney can challenge with supporting evidence.

Do not argue with the other driver at the scene. Stay calm, give your truthful account to the officer, and let the evidence do the talking. A car accident lawyer can later use the physical evidence, witness statements, and any dashcam footage to expose the inconsistencies in the other driver’s story.

How Texas Comparative Fault Rules Affect Your Case

Texas follows a modified comparative fault rule under Civil Practice and Remedies Code Chapter 33. Your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault. If you are found 51 percent or more responsible, you receive nothing. This is exactly why a lying driver is so dangerous to your claim. They are not just defending themselves. They are attacking your right to recover.

Say you were traveling south on I-35E near the Rayzor Ranch area when another driver merged into your lane without signaling. That driver later tells the insurance adjuster you were in their blind spot and failed to yield. If the adjuster accepts that version, your fault percentage goes up and your settlement goes down. Without strong evidence to counter the lie, the insurance company may accept the false narrative simply because it has no reason to dig deeper.

This is where fault determination becomes a fight, not just a paperwork process. Accident reconstruction experts can analyze vehicle damage patterns, road evidence, and physics to show how the crash actually happened. Black box data from newer vehicles records speed, braking, and steering inputs in the seconds before impact. Surveillance footage from businesses along University Drive (US-380) or Carroll Boulevard can show exactly who had the right of way. All of this evidence can directly contradict a false account and protect your recovery. A car accident attorney who handles fault disputes knows how to gather and use this type of evidence before it disappears.

What to Do If the Police Report Contains the Other Driver’s Lies

A police report is not the final word on fault. Officers document what they observe and what they are told. If the other driver gave a false account and no strong physical evidence contradicted it at the scene, that false account can end up in the official report. That is frustrating, but it does not mean your case is lost.

You can submit a supplemental statement to the reporting agency to correct inaccuracies. Your attorney can present additional evidence, including photos, witness statements, expert analysis, and surveillance footage, to challenge the report’s conclusions during the claims process or in litigation. Insurance adjusters are trained to investigate. If the other driver’s story does not match the physical evidence, a thorough investigation will expose that gap.

If errors or false statements appear in a crash report filed with TxDOT, Texas Transportation Code Section 550.068 addresses the process for modifying a written collision report. Acting quickly matters here. Evidence fades, witnesses move on, and surveillance footage gets overwritten. The Texas statute of limitations for personal injury claims is two years from the date of the crash, but waiting that long to act puts your evidence at serious risk.

If you were injured and the other driver is not being honest, contact Chandler Ross Injury Attorneys at (940) 800-2500. Our team serves clients throughout Denton County and the surrounding area. A car accident lawyer from our firm can review your case, help you understand your options, and work to build the strongest possible claim on your behalf. Past results in any case depend on the specific facts and law involved and do not guarantee the same outcome in your matter.

Building a Strong Claim When the Truth Is in Dispute

When the other driver lies, winning your case comes down to evidence. The side with stronger, more credible evidence wins. That means you need to act fast and be thorough from the very beginning.

Start a personal injury journal. Write down your injuries, your pain levels, your medical appointments, and how the crash has affected your daily life. Keep every medical bill, prescription receipt, and treatment record. Document any missed work and gather pay stubs or employer statements to support a lost wages claim. These records build the factual foundation of your case and show the real impact of the crash on your life.

Your attorney can also subpoena phone records to check whether the other driver was texting at the time of the crash. In commercial vehicle cases, your attorney can request driver logs and company records. If the crash involved a rideshare driver or a delivery driver, corporate insurance policies and dispatch records become part of the evidence picture. In cases involving serious injuries like traumatic brain injuries, spinal cord damage, or broken bones, the stakes are high enough that a thorough investigation is not optional. It is essential.

Chandler Ross Injury Attorneys handles car accident cases throughout Denton and surrounding communities, including clients who have been hurt on dangerous stretches of I-35, at busy Denton intersections, and in crashes involving uninsured or dishonest drivers. If you need a car accident attorney who will fight for the truth in your case, call us at (940) 800-2500 for a free consultation. Attorney Chandler Ross is responsible for the content of this page, with a principal office in Denton, Texas. Results in any case depend on the unique facts and circumstances involved.

FAQs About What to Do When the Other Driver Lies About the Accident

Can the other driver face criminal charges for lying about a car accident in Texas?

Yes. Under Texas Penal Code Section 37.08, knowingly giving false information to a police officer during an official investigation is a Class B misdemeanor. If the driver also lied to the insurance company to affect a claim, that conduct can rise to insurance fraud under Texas Penal Code Section 35.02, which carries penalties ranging from a misdemeanor to a felony depending on the dollar amount involved. These charges do not happen automatically. They require evidence and, typically, a formal complaint or investigation.

What if the police report already reflects the other driver’s false version of events?

A police report is not the final word on fault. You can submit a supplemental statement to the reporting agency, and your attorney can present physical evidence, witness accounts, and expert analysis to challenge the report’s findings during the claims process or in court. Texas Transportation Code Section 550.068 addresses modification of written collision reports. Acting quickly is important because evidence can disappear fast.

How does Texas comparative fault law affect my case if the other driver blames me?

Texas uses a modified comparative fault rule under Civil Practice and Remedies Code Chapter 33. Your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault. If you are found 51 percent or more responsible, you recover nothing. A lying driver is trying to push your fault percentage higher. Strong evidence, including photos, witness statements, dashcam footage, and accident reconstruction analysis, is your best defense against that strategy.

How soon should I contact a lawyer if I think the other driver is lying?

As soon as possible. Surveillance footage gets overwritten, witnesses forget details, and physical evidence at the scene disappears quickly. The sooner an attorney can begin investigating, the better your chances of preserving the evidence needed to counter a false account. Texas also has a two-year statute of limitations for personal injury claims, but waiting anywhere near that long puts your evidence at serious risk.

Can I still recover compensation if the insurance company initially sides with the other driver?

Yes. An insurance adjuster’s initial determination is not the end of your claim. If you have evidence that contradicts the other driver’s account, your attorney can present that evidence to challenge the insurer’s findings. If the insurer refuses to act in good faith, your attorney can pursue the claim through litigation. The key is having organized, credible evidence and a clear legal strategy from the start. Call Chandler Ross Injury Attorneys at (940) 800-2500 to discuss your specific situation.

More Resources About FAQs About Car Accidents in Denton, TX